I thought I'd put this put ages ago, but maybe not.
It's from the big paper. I had it on the web, but it's down. Still trying to find a real home for it. Basic notes, here.
The photo collage above is the best simple debunking I know of philosophers' arguments about Duchamp. The images are Ingres' La Source, Courbet's Origin of the World, a Sevres porcelain (1921) after an 18th century original by Etienne Maurice Falconet, and Duchamp's Fountain. The only thing I should need to add is that the Courbet was made for private view. The same holds of course for any urinal.
Duchamp/ Hitchcock. Notes, here.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhXtsUGKM5ltcEXiTcnwHootx-kU0RXRdKu4VeBt-EiC9NQGKIUIWPTG_niW0nwy-bpSy_4o6Ko5cpZsND3bpohaFB8tJbdK5mTNYapXWBj_8TsvcR1rT7r7L_S7w3TRhsLS1reew/w640-h212/duchamp-stewart2.jpg)
Hitchcock/Warhol 5/4/09 The whole post is repeated below
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgMn7MlH5D6QgFLQMyby8mkPkcXFbiP4xxUA92nWCb8YXJWE97iquzD2dfipeK_KjqtlsX_YPDclLs6dvSkf_R6giCaoF_Zjen7h6jR_GBkojJShYlxiJ9A_jLJ82eXDEEQKBUefg/w640-h640/2elvis.jpg)
Andy Warhol, Double Elvis, 1963
A doubled image of a fake cowboy -a movie image- played by a pop "icon," and beneath that of a person: Elvis Aaron Presley.
Two images of an image, of an image, of a man. And an image of psychosis.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhbE9M07CDcPWxcqtkxz6kXCM1TlIaiZGUFqEfdbMlaDc_K5mpSDF290Eg0czHxUWO8cGY3oGulGEhbYRAMcokzCVdBzP47pNWiuDk5hTYn8k27WHNVlbgR4IeWZVL89GRJZUCOpg/s1600/vertigo2.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjkqIMuCFIVag4RCn_QHmFUXWhRW9wMbP11UTG4fnmqsF7ckF_5f8GEQOvq07WCPKwPaPpClVtSmL68Qcmm0KGxvhEE-rbINL_cLBzQWNvOp0Z484zDF01-cnoa-9g7RrB2RtVDlQ/s400/vertigo.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiOWEQaU4H1tY0NiF6c9TqfZDiX904YrVzfoZNEmT2NVNT3Rkbun5mEl1psYzYAUdbnYL44VTglTyZBmeQVfpTysbrMwOA_9SEHxpkKq0ow3F8tCJ9AQGY07zqYe7H9lyWjRJeF4Q/s1600/psycho.jpg)
Alfred Hitchcock, Vertigo, 1958, and Psycho, 1960.
I shouldn't have to point out, but I will, that the spiral image also is from Vertigo.
All of these ended up in the paper.
----
2020. Noel Carroll's reply: "I am not sure why you sent this to me. I'm a philosopher not an art critic."
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comment moderation is enabled.