As'ad AbuKhalil

I asked ChatGPT whether Israel is racist and whether South Africa under apartheid is racist. See the difference.

was South Africa under apartheid racist?

The system of apartheid in South Africa, which existed from 1948 to 1994, was a system of institutionalized racial segregation and discrimination. It was based on the belief that different racial groups should be separated and that the white minority should have greater political and economic power than the non-white majority. The laws and policies of apartheid restricted the rights and freedoms of non-white South Africans, and perpetuated racial inequality in almost every aspect of life. Under apartheid, non-white

South Africans were denied the right to vote, were forced to live in separate and inferior neighborhoods, were restricted in their movement and were not allowed to marry or have sexual relations with white South Africans. In this sense, it is widely considered that the system of apartheid in South Africa was racist as it was based on the idea of white superiority and institutionalized racial discrimination.

Is Israel racist?

The question of whether Israel is racist is a complex and controversial one that is the subject of ongoing debate. Some argue that Israel's treatment of Palestinians, particularly in the occupied territories, constitutes racism. They cite discriminatory laws, unequal access to resources, and human rights abuses as evidence of this. Others argue that Israel is not racist, but rather is defending itself against terrorism and that its actions are necessary for its own security. They point to Israel's democratic system, in which Arab citizens have the right to vote and hold office, as evidence of its commitment to equality. It is important to note that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a complex and deeply rooted issue with a long history, and there are valid arguments on both sides.

---

jump forward to December